Cartagena or Medellín? We're Biased, But Here's the Honest Split

Quick answer

Pick Cartagena if you want the Caribbean, a walkable 16th-century walled city and boats to islands; pick Medellín if you want mild mountain weather, a big modern city and green day trips. The blunt difference is climate and altitude: Medellín sits around 1,500m up with an annual average near 22C, while we're at sea level and hot and humid year-round. They're a little over an hour apart by plane, so on a trip of seven days or more you don't have to choose. On a short trip you do, and the deciding question is whether you want to be in the water or in the hills.

A city spread across a valley with mountains behind it

We'll declare the interest first: we run a small hotel on Carrera 7 in San Diego, inside Cartagena's walls, so of course we want you here. That said, we send people to Medellín all the time, usually the ones who tell us at breakfast that they're melting.

Because that's the real fork in the road, and it isn't about culture or nightlife or which city is prettier. It's temperature. Medellín sits in a valley at roughly 1,500 metres, which gives it an annual average around 22C and the nickname about eternal spring. We're at sea level on the Caribbean, which means hot and humid all year, every year, no reprieve in the evening. Everyone has a strong opinion about which of those they'd rather sleep in, and most people know their own answer immediately.

Everything else follows from geography. We have a walled colonial city you can cross on foot in twenty minutes, a working port, and boats leaving for islands every morning. Medellín has a big modern metro system, cable cars up the hillsides, and green country within an hour's drive. You can't get our sea there and you can't get their evenings here.

The good news is that the two cities are a little over an hour apart by plane, and the route is one of the busiest in the country. If your trip is a week or longer, the correct answer is both, and the order that works best is Medellín first, Cartagena second, so you finish at the beach rather than starting there and spending the rest of the trip wishing you were back.

If your trip is three to five days, pick one. Two cities plus two airport days out of a short trip leaves you with a lot of logistics and not much sitting still.

CartagenaMedellín
Where it is Caribbean coast, sea levelAndes, a valley at around 1,500m
Climate Hot and humid year-roundMild year-round, annual average around 22C
The main draw A walled 16th-century city, plus the seaA big modern city with mountains around it
Getting around On foot inside the walls, taxis everywhere elseMetro and cable cars
Beaches Yes, plus boats to the islandsNone, it's landlocked
Best for A short, walkable, water-based tripLonger stays, day trips into green country
Distance apart Just over an hour by planeJust over an hour by plane

Book your stay at Townhouse Cartagena